Setting the context
A few days prior, a substitution was approved for Astralis as their Danish captain, Alexander "br0" Bro, was benched for Casper "cadiaN" Møller over a “medical emergency.” The decision came in after rosters had been locked in a month ago. According to the tournament's rulebook, teams can apply for an emergency substitution after the roster deadline "due to issues such as illness, injury, and travel disruption," and "the acceptance or rejection of an emergency replacement will be decided by BLAST on a case by case basis in its sole discretion."
The problem, however, is that BLAST did not share what kind of medical emergency br0 was undergoing, as such a decision at least warrants a proper explanation. In fact, many believe br0 is healthy and well according to his agent, Fabian Broich, which has thrown BLAST into a serious controversy about this decision. The agent took to X (formerly Twitter) and said: “According to the tournament's rulebook, teams can apply for an emergency replacement after the roster deadline "due to issues such as illness, injury, and travel disruption," and "the acceptance or rejection of an emergency replacement will be decided by BLAST on a case by case basis in its sole discretion."
Making matters worse
With all the information at hand, BLAST should have never approved of this substitution under any circumstances. Moreover, what makes matters worse is that BLAST has rejected more reasonable requests in the past, all of which goes to show the double standard being applied here.
For instance, during 2022’s BLAST Premier Spring Groups, k0nfig had been cleared to substitute for FaZe Clan despite being listed on HEROIC’s extended squad while other squads had their substitute requests denied. The matter was eventually rectified as BLAST cited “miscommunication” on their end whilst promising to improve details around roster locks, something we have yet to see.
A more recent example is when HEROIC requested a sub ahead of this year’s Fall Groups due to the transfer of nicoodoz and coach sAw’s inactive player status. However, according to HEROIC’s director of esports Robin Nymann: “We requested an emergency sub whilst having sAw and nicoodoz listed. nicoodoz was being transferred prior to the event, and sAw is not an active player. We were declined, then appealed the decision, and got declined again.”
Even the staff are against this
Commentator Janko “YNk” Paunovic hinted at potential favoritism after the latest Astralis substituion was confirmed. “With Valve ranking points on the line, this stuff just shouldn’t be able to fly anymore, RMR seeding is just around the corner!” he said, even joking on the ESL Pro League broadcast last week that Astralis should use their winnings to pay br0’s medical bills.
Fellow caster Jason “moses” O’Toole was relatively more direct: “Saying he has a medical emergency so you can sub in his replacement is impressively scummy even for Astralis. If it really is a straight-up lie there should be a heavy punishment from TOs upon the Astralis org,”
As far as why such favoritism was met out to Astralis, many suspect a collusion between BLAST and their parent company, RFRSH Entertainment, who previously owned Astralis. While the two were forced to part ways after Valve made it mandatory to disclose business relationships with other participants or organizers, this is our best bet at the moment.
